Compare and contrast compliance conformity and obedience

Both conformity and compliance are prevalent in all types of groups, but first is important to point out the differences between these two types of behavior.

Compare and contrast compliance conformity and obedience

This essay looks at the concepts of conformity, compliance, and obedience and lays out the similiarities and differences between them by looking at the factors that influence each.

It concludes that conformity stands apart from compliance and obedience, which share more similarities than differences. The reasons for this may be evolutionary in nature.

Compare and contrast compliance conformity and obedience

Conformity, compliance, and obedience are forms of social influence which strongly affect our behaviour is social situations, from following fashions and unwritten social norms which organise our behaviour, to committing immoral acts because we are commanded to by someone who appears to be in a position of authority.

This essay looks at the similarities and differences between the three, looking specifically at the factors that influence each three. In conclusion we find that two of the forms of social influence are very similar, almost interchangeable, while the third stands alone with influencing factors different from the other two.

References :

Conformity Conformity is the tendency for people to change their behaviour and paradigm to fit social norms. The Asch experiment involved subjects performing a perception task, saying which of a selection of lines matched a control line in length.

Unbeknown to the subject the other participants in the room were all confederates, and the seating was arranged so that the confederates would each give their answer to the trial in turn, with the subject giving their answer last. On critical trials the confederates would all give the same incorrect answer to the question.

This showed that the normative behaviour of being silent had been unconsciously activated in those subjects who saw the library picture.

Difference Between Conformity and Obedience | Difference Between

There seem to be three main reasons for conformity: Each of these could be argued to have ethological roots: Compliance Compliance is one person yielding to the requests of another. Much research has been carried out into what influences compliance.

Conformity has been studied most famously by Milgram In his experiment a subject was told to apply electric shocks of increasing strength to a learner, actually a confederate, whenever they made mistakes on a memory task.

Similarities The three concepts of conformity, compliance, and obedience are interrelated and share a number of similarities. Both compliance and conformity have been shown to be improved by positive inter-personal attitudes.

Other Subject Areas

Ingratiation and flattery has been shown to correlate with improved compliance, as has performing small favours for the subject and a positive self-presentation Gordon, Drawing attention to incidental similarities between the requestor and the requestee has likewise been shown to improve compliance Burger et al.

Similarly cohesiveness of the group has been shown to affect conformity Crandall, Compliance and obedience also have a similarity in the foot-in-the-door approach.

This is reflected in the Milgram experiments on obedience where the subject built up from smaller shocks to larger ones. Conformity, compliance, and obedience are all subject to the effects of informational social influence.

Studies have also shown that the rate of obedience to destructive commands drops sharply if the participants are reminded that the weight of responsibility falls on their shoulders Hamilton,i.

Finally obedience and compliance can, for the sake of much of the above, be considered the same thing as while compliance is a request and obedience is an order, both are requesting that the subject comply with the demand.

Differences Compliance and obedience have one main difference: While one invites the subject to decline, a command carries with it the social expectations of obedience.

Conformity, Compliance, and Obedience

Conformity is generally an internalising of the social norms, where the subject takes these and incorporates them into their own paradigm. However public compliance and obedience do not necessarily belie private attitudes and beliefs.

While compliance and obedience are the result of social expectations, self-gain, and fear of conflict or punishment, conformity also has a stronger ethological cause:This purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast the concepts of compliance, obedience and conformity and also to look at the factors that influence each one of them to see the differences and similarities between them.

In social psychology, the main difference between compliance and obedience is a figure of authority.. Compliance is simply requesting someone to do something and they comply. You use logical reasoning and persuasion to accomplish compliance.

Two aspects that are important in group behavior are conformity and compliance. Both conformity and compliance are prevalent in all types of groups, but first is important to point out the differences between these two types of behavior.

In this section, we discuss additional ways in which people influence others. The topics of conformity, social influence, obedience, and group processes demonstrate the power of the social situation to change our thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.

Two aspects that are important in group behavior are conformity and compliance. Both conformity and compliance are prevalent in all types of groups, but first is important to point out the differences between these two types of behavior.

sherif, asch, milgram, variations for milgram, differentiate conformity, graph of high and low motivation and conformity - highly motivated to be correct and i don't know the task, i look to others for the answer in order to be correct.

Conformity, Compliance, and Obedience - Psychology - Oxford Bibliographies